FREE 2-Day Shipping from NYC! Order
FREE 2-Day Shipping from NYC! Order
The classic Pumpernickel Bagel may get overlooked because no one is quite sure what goes well with it. The simple answer is, everything goes well with our savory pumpernickel!
If you enjoy a topping on any other bagel, odds are you will like it on a Pumpernickel too! That said, there are some time-tested toppings that can take a tasty plain New Yorker Pumpernickel Bagel to a new level of flavor.
Don’t want 12 Pumpernickel Bagels? You can also Build Your Own Assortment!
Allergen Statement
New Yorker Bagels is not a certified nut free environment, although none of our products contain any nuts. Residual nut contamination from our ingredient supplies is possible, though unlikely.
The only common allergens that are present in our products are wheat and sesame. All of our bagels contain wheat.
Vegan Statement
None of our bagels contain animal products - they are 100% Vegan.
Delicious !!!!
The Best
NYC boy here,these are overthetop amazing.
And super large
Pumpernickel Bagels
Love how there is a snap to them but are chewy on the inside. Yummy!!
Surprisingly soft for pumpernickel, which is usually tough.
Quality is wonderful and there are 18-19 choices, all worth exploring,
My only thought is that we all independently believed the bagels can be made less meaty- meaning we cut each bagel horizontally in 3. LOL. Next time, I will mix and match the choices better. Don't under-estimate pumpernickel. It's my favorite and lightly toasted, adding houmous or baba gnoosh is great or Acme NY white fish -also superb.
Great
Delicious !!!!
The Best
NYC boy here,these are overthetop amazing.
And super large
Pumpernickel Bagels
Love how there is a snap to them but are chewy on the inside. Yummy!!
Surprisingly soft for pumpernickel, which is usually tough.
Quality is wonderful and there are 18-19 choices, all worth exploring,
My only thought is that we all independently believed the bagels can be made less meaty- meaning we cut each bagel horizontally in 3. LOL. Next time, I will mix and match the choices better. Don't under-estimate pumpernickel. It's my favorite and lightly toasted, adding houmous or baba gnoosh is great or Acme NY white fish -also superb.
Great
Copyright © 2025 New Yorker Bagels.
The classic Pumpernickel Bagel may get overlooked because no one is quite sure what goes well with it. The simple answer is, everything goes well with our savory pumpernickel!
If you enjoy a topping on any other bagel, odds are you will like it on a Pumpernickel too! That said, there are some time-tested toppings that can take a tasty plain New Yorker Pumpernickel Bagel to a new level of flavor.
Don’t want 12 Pumpernickel Bagels? You can also Build Your Own Assortment!
Allergen Statement
New Yorker Bagels is not a certified nut free environment, although none of our products contain any nuts. Residual nut contamination from our ingredient supplies is possible, though unlikely.
The only common allergens that are present in our products are wheat and sesame. All of our bagels contain wheat.
Vegan Statement
None of our bagels contain animal products - they are 100% Vegan.
Delicious !!!!
The Best
NYC boy here,these are overthetop amazing.
And super large
Pumpernickel Bagels
Love how there is a snap to them but are chewy on the inside. Yummy!!
Surprisingly soft for pumpernickel, which is usually tough.
Quality is wonderful and there are 18-19 choices, all worth exploring,
My only thought is that we all independently believed the bagels can be made less meaty- meaning we cut each bagel horizontally in 3. LOL. Next time, I will mix and match the choices better. Don't under-estimate pumpernickel. It's my favorite and lightly toasted, adding houmous or baba gnoosh is great or Acme NY white fish -also superb.
Great