With our Bagel of the Month options, you can easily get fresh New York City bagels delivered automatically, at an interval you choose.
Subscription customers always enjoy 10% savings, in addition to the free 2-day shipping we provide. When you start a subscription you'll earn 500 sesame seeds in Bagel Dough Rewards!
Join over 7,000 New York bagel lovers!
Save on every order!
There are 3 different ways to join 'da club:
1. Custom Bagel of the Month
The Most Control.
- Select 2 bagel flavors (4 for 2 dozen, 6 for 3 dozen)
- Pause your subscription
- Change frequency
- Change shipping address
- Change your next delivery date
Update payment info
To Join:
- Select either 1 dozen ($28.80), 2 dozen ($39.60) or 3 dozen ($52.60) bagels.
- Select your desired bagel flavors.
- Click "Subscribe" and set subscription frequency.
- Click "Secure Checkout" to check out.
2. Specific Flavor Subscription
Simplest. If you 🧡 one specific bagel.
You Can:
- Pause your subscription
- Change frequency
- Change bagel flavors between shipments (swap)
- Change shipping address
- Change your next delivery date
- Update payment info
To Join:
- Select the single bagel flavor you want.
- Click the "Subscribe to save" option, then select your Delivery Frequency.
- Click "Add to Cart" to check out.
3. Bagel of the Month Gift
Send a Bagel of the Month to someone special.
How Gifts Work:
- Bagel flavors are preset
- Gifts are pre-paid
- Select a 3, 6, 9 or 12 month gift
To Send:
- Go to our Prepaid Bagel of the Month Gifts page.
- Select the gift you wish to send and click on it.
- Select the flavors you want and then click "Secure Checkout".
More Info
Please be sure to create an account when you check out. Accounts are optional, but you cannot manage your subscription without an account.
Login to your account to pause, edit or change date of your next shipment! If you started a subscription without an account, you can create one now to be able to manage your subscription, just be sure to use the same email address you checked out with!
Bagel Subscription Club Notes:
- If your next order processing date falls on a Friday, Saturday or Sunday, your bagels will be shipped the following Monday.
- An order cannot be paused or changed after 2 days of its next processing date.
- All Subscribers agree to our Terms of Service.
Kosher Certified
100% Vegan