Hand-rolled Bagel Gift Boxes
Hand-rolled Fresh Bagel Gift Boxes
Fresh from NYC with Free 2-Day Shipping
PACKED IN A GIFT BOX 🔸 HAND-ROLLED 🔸 ADD A GIFT MESSAGE 🔸 STAR-K KOSHER
Fresh 'n fast with Free 2-Day Shipping
HAND-ROLLED IN NYC 🥯 SHIPPED FRESH 🥯 STAR-K KOSHER
Fresh Bagels from New York City
Free 2-Day Shipping
Surprise and delight with a gift box of hand-rolled NYC bagels. Add a Gift Note.
Express Shipping Included.
Red-Swirled Christmas Bagels
Available for a short time only! Our hand-rolled plain NYC bagels with a special red-swirl added to the dough.
Free Overnight Shipping.
$39.50
NYC Bagel Gift Boxes
The Astoria
A gift to mix it up! Includes 2 exclusives: French Toast and Jalapeño Red Pepper.
A gift to mix it up! Includes Everything, Poppy, plus two exclusives: French Toast and Jalapeño Red Pepper.
$44 - $59
Custom Box - 2 Dozen
You select 4 of our 22 available varieties to send to someone special!
A gift to mix it up! Includes Everything, Poppy, plus two exclusives: French Toast and Jalapeño Red Pepper.
$44
Fresh Bagels with Spreads
The New Yorker + Spreads
All-time best selling fresh NYC bagels. We add yummy spreads to top 'em!
$62 - $86.75
2 Dozen + Spreads
Select 4 varieties to send, We add 24 yummy packets to top 'em all!
$62
Fresh Bagels with Coffee
The New Yorker + Coffee
Most popular New York Bagels paired with our premium instant coffees.
$64 - $89.75
2 Dozen + Coffee
Select 4 New York bagel varieties and we add coffees to pair 'em.
$64
Fresh Bagels with Spreads & Coffee
The New Yorker + Spreads + Coffee
Best selling NYC bagels with spreads and coffee for a complete package!
$92 - $116.75
2 Dozen + Spreads + Coffee
Select 4 varieties and we'll add yummy spreads and coffee too!
$92
Bagel of the Month Gifts
Free 2-Day Shipping Each Month!
↓
Fresh Bagel Gift Cards
Let customers speak for us
Taste and texture are very satisfying! My husband has particular tastes and he is enjoying these bagels! He grew up in Westchester County and lived in NYC for 10 years after graduating from college, so he appreciates NYC cuisine! I certainly love these as well. It will be a challenge to keep us supplied!😸😸🥯🥯🥯
After living in New York, I was disappointed about the bagel and pizza situation in California. The bagel or pizza crust always was missing that X Factor. That New York taste that makes for an amazing taste experience - whether one is munching on a toasted bagel for breakfast or trying to not get cheese/ grease on one's shirt while standing at the local pizzeria counter. Fortunately, I decided to try New Yorker bagels and EUREKA! After, twenty nine years of missing true New York bagels I finally found the bagels (Everything & Plain😋) that hit the sweet spot. Yep, I'll be ordering more from this Company...now I just got find a New York pizza company that ships to California.
The best bagels I’ve ever had the pleasure of eating! A true work of gastronomy!
Haven’t had a bagel this good since leaving Long Island NY….Thank you so much!! Delicious!! ;)
Best bagels I’ve had in years. I was hesitant at first but so glad the pictures drew me in and I ordered. The whole family loved them. Well done! We will be ordering again soon.
Super bagels. Best that I have ever had.
We’re in L.A. and it’s impossible to find genuine New York bagels until now. These are the big New York bagels I remember from my childhood and my kids love them too.
Delicious
Excellent taste! Super fresh and soft! I will definitely be back to order more!
Everything is always my go too!
Our package arrived a few days ago and we are thoroughly enjoying our bagels! Some have been frozen for enjoying in later days. Really delish!
They are delicious! But I am a diabetic and I neglected to check the carbs before ordering. They are high! But I am eating only a half of one at a time. They are great!
Excellent bagels. I’m originally from Brooklyn and they taste like I remember them.
3 Dozen Bagel Gift Crate
Marble is my favorite-good for any meal any time of day and any topping, sweet or savory.
2 Dozen Hand-rolled NYC Bagels
What customers think about the store
New Yorker Bagels delivers fresh, authentic NYC bagels nationwide. Customers rave about the large size, chewy texture, and delicious flavors, though some found them too bready. Fast shipping, but occasional issues with stale bagels upon arrival. A taste of New...
AI-generated from customer reviews.
Need to send a lotta gifts? Corporate gifts?
Contact us for our corporate order form. Just send us your list and we'll take care of everything!
From the World's Largest Fresh Bagel Bakery.
Learn More About Us:
Need to send a lotta gifts?
Corporate gifts?
Contact us for our corporate order form. Just send us your list and we'll take care of everything!
What do New Yorkers think of our hand-rolled bagels?
