Delicious Bagel Gifts
Fresh From New York City
Free 2-Day Shipping
World's Best
Bagel Gifts, Fresh From New York City
Free 2-Day Shipping
BAKED IN NYC 🔸 HAND-ROLLED 🔸 SHIPPED FRESH 🔸 STAR-K KOSHER
BAKED IN NYC 🔸 HAND-ROLLED 🔸 SHIPPED FRESH 🔸 STAR-K KOSHER
Delight with a best-selling fresh bagel gift:
Surprise and delight with a gift box of authentic NYC bagels!
Hand-rolled in New York City.
Surprise and delight with a gift box of hand-rolled NYC bagels. Add a Gift Note.
Express Shipping Included.
Red-Swirled Christmas Bagels
Available for a short time only! Our hand-rolled plain NYC bagels with a special red-swirl added to the dough.
Free Overnight Shipping.
$39.50
The Astoria - 2 Dozen
A gift to mix it up! Includes Everything, Poppy,
plus two exclusives: French Toast and Jalapeño Red Pepper.
A gift to mix it up! Includes Everything, Poppy, plus two exclusives: French Toast and Jalapeño Red Pepper.
$42 $59
1 Dozen + Spreads
Select two hand-rolled, and we add yummy spreads to top 'em!
$42.50 $49
Or Save 10% with a Bagel-of-the-Month Option ↓
Free 2-Day Shipping Each Month!
Or Save 10% with a Bagel-of-the-Month Option
Free 2-Day Shipping Each Month!
↓
Let customers speak for us
These are fantastic bagels. We miss Brooklyn, this brings us back home!
Fresh when they get to you. Really large size and they freeze well. I am hooked!
Also tasty and just plain great.
Great Bagels, textures, taste, freshness.
Best ever-although it would be nice if you also sold the cream cheese spread
These were ordered as a replacement for some that were delayed in shipment. They were originally supposed to arrive on 28 September—the day after Helene hit. New Yorker Bagels wisely delayed shipment, and they arrived the day after my electricity was restored—fresh and tasty. I'm looking forward to ordering more flavors.
These bagels are the best. Always arrives on time and fresh.
1 Dozen Hand-rolled NYC Bagels
Great product
These arrived to me in two days and they were delicious, will definitely be ordering again!!
Wow! Great bagels!
Great bagels!
Those bagels were absolutely delicious
I have ordered from you 3 times now, and the first time I ordered, I ordered regular bagels while they were Wonderful but really big so I decided to try the mini bagels they are perfect size for a for a sandwich! They are so delicious! the only thing I have an issue with is I can't get the minis in Onion, or Garlic So I settled for my other favorites, Everything, and Sesame Hopefully one of these days they will make them available to order!
I lived in Massachusetts before moving to Florida. The bagels here are awful. Glad I found new york bagels that deliver here. When I go visit family once a year I get 4 dozen to bring back to Florida.
1 Dozen Bagel Gift Box
What customers think about the store
New Yorker Bagels delivers fresh, authentic NYC bagels nationwide. Customers rave about the large size, chewy texture, and delicious flavors, though some found them too bready. Fast shipping, but occasional issues with stale bagels upon arrival. A taste of New...
AI-generated from customer reviews.
From the World's Largest Fresh Bagel Bakery.
Learn More About Us:
Need to send a lotta gifts?
Corporate gifts?
Contact us for our corporate order form. Just send us your list and we'll take care of everything!
What do New Yorkers think of our hand-rolled bagels?
All of our bagels:
- Rolled by Hand in New York City
- Shipped fresh - 2-day shipping included
- No preservatives of any kind
- Star-K, pas Yisroel Kosher certified
- Packed in a New Yorker Bagels gift box
- Add a gift message
All of our bagels:
- Rolled By Hand in New York City
- Shipped fresh - 2-day or Overnight
- No preservatives of any kind
- Certified Star-K pas Yisroel Kosher
- Packed in a New Yorker Bagels gift box
- Add a gift message
